The glorification in HBCU BAND poll ranking of larger size bands at the expense of smaller size bands

Indulgence Suffocations is a harmful concept and needs to be air out in the HBCU band world. The glorification in HBCU BAND poll ranking of larger size band programs at the expense of smaller size bands at times is not based on how well you sound, but the size of the band. This trending is becoming a hindrance to proper band ranking for good sounding smaller HBCU band programs. Lack of numbers for too many fans and judges suffocates anything pleasantly fresh or good sounding. Just what do I imply? Look at it this way if your band is not part of the SWAC or MEAC, the chance of your band getting recognized as a top tier band is almost zero. Even if you are a large band, not members of the SWAC or MEAC, you get looked over many times for the top spots or any spots in the ranking battleground. I am not saying certain bands not get a due reconnection for excellent musicianship. But music powerfulness and bodies covering the whole football field need not get ten thousand bonus points. Our smaller HBCU bands play the same music as the larger HBCU bands, and they play music well. But they suffer from many thanking that a smaller college or University can not be as good as the big boys. As a friend once said, if you did not break my eardrum, you not much of a band, and look, they only have one Drum major. Whenever money is in the game, as others have said before me, it can suffocate anything and anyone else, and I think some have been seduced. Everyone's attention span is getting shorter. So what do you consider that can help.? ---- James Stewart 11/17/2019

Views: 338

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

We need examples. Post a video of a "small band" that's good and should be ranked; yet, they are overlooked because they are not SWAC or MEAC.

 



John Brown said:

We need examples. Post a video of a "small band" that's good and should be ranked; yet, they are overlooked because they are not SWAC or MEAC.

Battle of the Big 3 BOTB | Allen University | "Band of Gold" (Oct.20.2019)

https://youtu.be/I9vHZ6UATvg

 

What a great honor for Allen University, a two-year program Band of Gold to be rank in December the Seventh best division two HBCU in the nation. But best of all, our ladies at Allen University, the dancers are rank number one in HBCU division two. What a great honor. The legendary band director Eddie Ellis

Wow. Allen decent. This Allen's 2nd?3rd? year right? They doing well in such a short period of time. They already better than quite a few SIAC bands thats been going for years; i.e. Clark, Morehouse, Savannah State, etc. But I understand where you coming from; you just want the small programs to get there due recognition. 

I ask them to list us on the Videos by Category list mounts ago as you can see we are not listed on this site.



John Brown said:

Wow. Allen decent. This Allen's 2nd?3rd? year right? They doing well in such a short period of time. They already better than quite a few SIAC bands thats been going for years; i.e. Clark, Morehouse, Savannah State, etc. But I understand where you coming from; you just want the small programs to get there due recognition. 

Reply to Discussion

RSS

© 2020   Created by Marchingsport.com.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service