First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orleans stand out from other cities. For example in New Orleans majorettes use 2 batons instead of 1. I have noticed how dance routines are done and how bands perform and I can say the approach New Orleans has is not like any other. What can be the reason?

You need to be a member of bandhead.org to add comments!

Join bandhead.org

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Each area or region has their own style.... look at the bands on the east coast.... look at florida bands compared to the ones in Houston....each area brings something different to the table

  • Yjr Make Up of a New Orleans Marching Unit is the Biggest Difference. most people won't understand it or respect it until they understand it as a marching band enthusiast would tell them.

    Here's what I see

    • Our Color guard is not the same as a Color guard anywhere else.
    • Our Color Guard is Based off of Millitary Guardsmen such as the Navy Color Guard
    • Our Color Guard & Female Flag Teams have nothing to do with each other... Its not a winter guard.
    • Our Color Guards are commonly known as Drill Team / Drill Squad (i'll expound on the difference later)
    • Unlike a Winter Guard, Our Flag Twirlers Twirl 2 short  yet sometimes HUGE Flags ..But Even when they held one flag, they had nothing to do with the Color Guards
    • Our flag Teams are Commonly Called FLAG TWIRLERS
    • Our Majorettes are Baton Twirlers,..Everywhere else, the dancers are called Majorettes (yet they twirl nothing) .. the reason they're  called that though is because  it was originally the majorettes who ditched the batons and began dancing without them
    • Our Majorettes Use 2 Batons and they March ..Baton Twirlers elsewhere Dance and Twirl.
    • Our Dance Team ... Dances ..lol...
    • Cheerleaders Commonly MARCH Parades.as a Pep Squad
    • All of it is not BETTER here, because most of all. We still Have Units 
    • Our Parade & Field set ups is fairly different than elsewhere due to all of these  entities within our units.
    • with Standards that haven't changed since 1964. and its HURT some programs.. others have gotten around the state and have learned "the way" of HBCU bands and other HS bands which have made them better...
    N.O bands dont do dance routines .because we have too many extra side shows to do them LOL.
    ..uhhh there's more but i dont feel like writing

  • Perfect explanation, Book!

  • i think it goes along with how new orleans as a city it different from any other city. its just a whole different cullture.

  • Is it true that Color guards were placed into the Marching Unit to protect the whole band during parade season? I guess the swinging of the flags will make people get out the way. Ive seen people cross through bands from out of town. But a full Line of Color guards help I believe.

  • It's only from a standpoint of Pageantry.  Their roll is to Guard the Colors .. Bearing Flags and Banners  with guns and swords (lol) ...   like a Bootleg ROTC that does a high knee lift LOL

    Banner Bearers, Rifle & Sword Bearers. that was your first 5 to 8 people people who Led the band to the battle.. as if the Band is the Army 

    Tall Flag Rockers came Later thanks to Fortier I also believe they as well as Booker T & John Mac were the Innovators behind the Drill Squad.where the Swordsmen and gunmen  would do routines with their "tools" ..eventually that turned into Dance Style steps and hip hop moves along with the High stepping challenges LOL 

    IMO I'd Rather see these dudes due Steps like a Frat ,, Or Public Enemies S1W .. aside from that now days its kinda Fruity

    Aside from that. I've noticed Improvements due to HBCU Exposure, The problem is, Alot of the sponsors have no experience beyond high school and their Alma mater

    Norfolk State's Spartan Guard was modeled after New Orleans' color guards.

    Grambling State used to have a color guard like N.O's before they went with females and or then Dropped the flag girls

    New Orleans Dance squads used to do a Hip Rock and wobbly arm movements and strut pretty similarly  through a whole parade or game .. Now days some of them dance and strut like HBCU dance teams.  and their even changing up Uniforms in mid game...That was so "NEW" to me after the storm, yet its a good thing .. Also. honestly the old isn't bad because its "Clean" and cant be criticized .. watch how folks begin when they think the dancers are getting too raunchy.  

    if you look at Carvers Dance Squad.. they dance like the J Settes .. Cohen's dance team does the Hip Rock. 

    The Majorettes (baton girls) and Flag teams have remained the same since the 80's..they still do the wobbly arm movements  & hip rock .. as well as the  "Step Step Up Kick":  ... and they do this simply because its the only thing the sponsors know ... they won't teach REAL techniques because they don't know any better.  The Difference between now and the 80's is .. The majorettes stopped wearing band style helmets ...lol  ... 

    Two Flags started at Landry in like 90

    Our Drum Majors Used to Direct the band (marching and song wise) 90%. of the time.. and Twirling the stick & HIGH STEPPING was always something GOOD.  now.. we have Dmajors doing JSU routines .. some who have it 100% others don't have it at all. I doubt that they even spend time IN the band room anymore .. Its not BAD its just messed up that they're all DIFFERENT yet all THE SAME lol

    On another note i quit lol


    Dj Drummerboy said:

    Is it true that Color guards were placed into the Marching Unit to protect the whole band during parade season? I guess the swinging of the flags will make people get out the way. Ive seen people cross through bands from out of town. But a full Line of Color guards help I believe.

     

    When it comes to style, why is New Orleans so different?
    First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orlea…
  • Book Landry did not start two flags. Two flags started at 35 in the late 70's early 80's. Our flag twirlers have been called double trouble because of that.

    The Book said:

    It's only from a standpoint of Pageantry.  Their roll is to Guard the Colors .. Bearing Flags and Banners  with guns and swords (lol) ...   like a Bootleg ROTC that does a high knee lift LOL

    Banner Bearers, Rifle & Sword Bearers. that was your first 5 to 8 people people who Led the band to the battle.. as if the Band is the Army 

    Tall Flag Rockers came Later thanks to Fortier I also believe they as well as Booker T & John Mac were the Innovators behind the Drill Squad.where the Swordsmen and gunmen  would do routines with their "tools" ..eventually that turned into Dance Style steps and hip hop moves along with the High stepping challenges LOL 

    IMO I'd Rather see these dudes due Steps like a Frat ,, Or Public Enemies S1W .. aside from that now days its kinda Fruity

    Aside from that. I've noticed Improvements due to HBCU Exposure, The problem is, Alot of the sponsors have no experience beyond high school and their Alma mater

    Norfolk State's Spartan Guard was modeled after New Orleans' color guards.

    Grambling State used to have a color guard like N.O's before they went with females and or then Dropped the flag girls

    New Orleans Dance squads used to do a Hip Rock and wobbly arm movements and strut pretty similarly  through a whole parade or game .. Now days some of them dance and strut like HBCU dance teams.  and their even changing up Uniforms in mid game...That was so "NEW" to me after the storm, yet its a good thing .. Also. honestly the old isn't bad because its "Clean" and cant be criticized .. watch how folks begin when they think the dancers are getting too raunchy.  

    if you look at Carvers Dance Squad.. they dance like the J Settes .. Cohen's dance team does the Hip Rock. 

    The Majorettes (baton girls) and Flag teams have remained the same since the 80's..they still do the wobbly arm movements  & hip rock .. as well as the  "Step Step Up Kick":  ... and they do this simply because its the only thing the sponsors know ... they won't teach REAL techniques because they don't know any better.  The Difference between now and the 80's is .. The majorettes stopped wearing band style helmets ...lol  ... 

    Two Flags started at Landry in like 90

    Our Drum Majors Used to Direct the band (marching and song wise) 90%. of the time.. and Twirling the stick & HIGH STEPPING was always something GOOD.  now.. we have Dmajors doing JSU routines .. some who have it 100% others don't have it at all. I doubt that they even spend time IN the band room anymore .. Its not BAD its just messed up that they're all DIFFERENT yet all THE SAME lol

    On another note i quit lol


    Dj Drummerboy said:

    Is it true that Color guards were placed into the Marching Unit to protect the whole band during parade season? I guess the swinging of the flags will make people get out the way. Ive seen people cross through bands from out of town. But a full Line of Color guards help I believe.

     

    When it comes to style, why is New Orleans so different?
    First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orlea…
  • thanks for that correction i've heard it 1000 times and you know when u hear the same story alot it seems true. but at the same time. alot of landry folks were only confined to things they saw on that side of the river LOL

    but you get the picture LOL

    Cee Jay said:

    Book Landry did not start two flags. Two flags started at 35 in the late 70's early 80's. Our flag twirlers have been called double trouble because of that.

    The Book said:

    It's only from a standpoint of Pageantry.  Their roll is to Guard the Colors .. Bearing Flags and Banners  with guns and swords (lol) ...   like a Bootleg ROTC that does a high knee lift LOL

    Banner Bearers, Rifle & Sword Bearers. that was your first 5 to 8 people people who Led the band to the battle.. as if the Band is the Army 

    Tall Flag Rockers came Later thanks to Fortier I also believe they as well as Booker T & John Mac were the Innovators behind the Drill Squad.where the Swordsmen and gunmen  would do routines with their "tools" ..eventually that turned into Dance Style steps and hip hop moves along with the High stepping challenges LOL 

    IMO I'd Rather see these dudes due Steps like a Frat ,, Or Public Enemies S1W .. aside from that now days its kinda Fruity

    Aside from that. I've noticed Improvements due to HBCU Exposure, The problem is, Alot of the sponsors have no experience beyond high school and their Alma mater

    Norfolk State's Spartan Guard was modeled after New Orleans' color guards.

    Grambling State used to have a color guard like N.O's before they went with females and or then Dropped the flag girls

    New Orleans Dance squads used to do a Hip Rock and wobbly arm movements and strut pretty similarly  through a whole parade or game .. Now days some of them dance and strut like HBCU dance teams.  and their even changing up Uniforms in mid game...That was so "NEW" to me after the storm, yet its a good thing .. Also. honestly the old isn't bad because its "Clean" and cant be criticized .. watch how folks begin when they think the dancers are getting too raunchy.  

    if you look at Carvers Dance Squad.. they dance like the J Settes .. Cohen's dance team does the Hip Rock. 

    The Majorettes (baton girls) and Flag teams have remained the same since the 80's..they still do the wobbly arm movements  & hip rock .. as well as the  "Step Step Up Kick":  ... and they do this simply because its the only thing the sponsors know ... they won't teach REAL techniques because they don't know any better.  The Difference between now and the 80's is .. The majorettes stopped wearing band style helmets ...lol  ... 

    Two Flags started at Landry in like 90

    Our Drum Majors Used to Direct the band (marching and song wise) 90%. of the time.. and Twirling the stick & HIGH STEPPING was always something GOOD.  now.. we have Dmajors doing JSU routines .. some who have it 100% others don't have it at all. I doubt that they even spend time IN the band room anymore .. Its not BAD its just messed up that they're all DIFFERENT yet all THE SAME lol

    On another note i quit lol


    Dj Drummerboy said:

    Is it true that Color guards were placed into the Marching Unit to protect the whole band during parade season? I guess the swinging of the flags will make people get out the way. Ive seen people cross through bands from out of town. But a full Line of Color guards help I believe.

     

    When it comes to style, why is New Orleans so different?
    First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orlea…
  • True. LOL

    The Book said:

    thanks for that correction i've heard it 1000 times and you know when u hear the same story alot it seems true. but at the same time. alot of landry folks were only confined to things they saw on that side of the river LOL

    but you get the picture LOL

    Cee Jay said:

    Book Landry did not start two flags. Two flags started at 35 in the late 70's early 80's. Our flag twirlers have been called double trouble because of that.

    When it comes to style, why is New Orleans so different?
    First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orlea…
  • true facts.



    Dj Drummerboy said:

    Is it true that Color guards were placed into the Marching Unit to protect the whole band during parade season? I guess the swinging of the flags will make people get out the way. Ive seen people cross through bands from out of town. But a full Line of Color guards help I believe.

    When it comes to style, why is New Orleans so different?
    First of all this is not to become a argument, but this more of a observation. I look at how Bands, Majorettes, Dance teams that perform in New Orlea…
This reply was deleted.